Environment and Social Psychology

The multifaceted determinants of Saudi foreign policy in the gulf: Interplay of domestic, ideational, and systemic factors

Waleed. F AlFaisal

Graduate School of Management, Management and Science University, University Drive Off Persiaran Olahraga, Shah Alam, Selangor, 40100, Malaysia

Aimi anuar

Graduate School of Management, Management and Science University, University Drive Off Persiaran Olahraga, Shah Alam, Selangor, 40100, Malaysia

DOI: https://doi.org/10.59429/esp.v10i10.3907

Keywords: gulf region; regional dynamics; interests; motivations; geopolitical

---

Abstract

Background: Saudi Arabia's foreign policy in the Gulf region (2011-2023) is driven by a complex interplay of interests, motivations, and regional dynamics. Existing scholarships often overlook the intricate interactions between these elements and lack a comprehensive theoretical framework synthesizing religious influence, regional standing, and dynamic leadership. Objective: This study aimed to address this gap by providing a more integrated and nuanced understanding of Saudi foreign policy. It sought to analyze the multi-faceted interactions among strategic security imperatives, economic motivations, geopolitical factors, religious influences, aspirations for regional leadership, and domestic political contexts. Methodologies: A mixed-methods approach was employed, integrating both qualitative and quantitative research methodologies. This involved semi-structured interviews with prominent policymakers and experts, subjected to thematic analysis, alongside the analysis of secondary economic, political, and security data within the Gulf. Neoclassical realism and constructivism served as theoretical frameworks, enabling a comprehensive exploration of both material and ideational factors influencing Saudi foreign policy. Results: The study revealed that Saudi foreign policy was fueled by aspirations for regional dominance, religious influence, and an urgent need for economic diversification. It shed light on how these internal motivations interacted with external regional dynamics, especially during the tumultuous era of 2011-2023, marked by the Arab Spring, the rise of ISIS, and increased tensions with Iran. Detailed case studies of interventions in Yemen, the Qatar crisis, and the establishment of relations with Israel elucidated the rationale behind key policy decisions. Challenges identified included domestic political constraints, economic diversification efforts, and ongoing regional instability. Conclusions: Saudi foreign policy is a complex and dynamic process shaped by the intricate interplay of internal drivers and external pressures. The study's integrated analysis transcended simplistic narratives, offering a thorough and nuanced understanding of these determinants. Recommendations: To successfully navigate the Gulf region’s complex geopolitical landscape and secure its future, Saudi Arabia requires a sophisticated and proactive strategy. This approach should blend assertiveness with diplomacy, prioritize economic diversification, foster strategic partnerships, and ensure a cohesive integration of both domestic and foreign policy.

---

References

[1]. 1.Ali, A. and L. Cochrane, Residency and citizenship in the Gulf: recent policy changes and future implications for the region. Comparative Migration Studies, 2024. 12(1).

[2]. 2.Mishra, R.K., Fresh water availability and its global challenge. British Journal of Multidisciplinary and Advanced Studies, 2023. 4(3): p. 1-78.

[3]. 3.Abuagla, A. and E. Badr, Challenges to implementation of the WHO Global Code of Practice on International Recruitment of Health Personnel: The case of Sudan. Human Resources for Health, 2016. 14.

[4]. 4.Bülbül Pehlivan, S., Security Strategy of Saudi Arabia as a Regional Power in the Unipolar System (2010-2020). Karadeniz Uluslararası Bilimsel Dergi, 2023(60): p. 140-156.

[5]. 5.Flynn, C. and S. Aldamer, The international political economy of Saudi Arabia: Sovereign fund and foreign policy. Digest of Middle East Studies, 2024. 33(2): p. 149-165.

[6]. 6.Becheikh, N., Political stability and economic growth in developing economies: lessons from Morocco, Tunisia and Egypt ten years after the Arab Spring. Insights into Regional Development, 2021. 3(2): p. 229-251.

[7]. 7.Memish, Z.A., et al., A New Era of National Guideline Development in Saudi Arabia. J Epidemiol Glob Health, 2022. 12(4): p. 373-379.

[8]. 8.Berrocal, M., et al., Constructing collective identities and solidarity in premiers’ early speeches on COVID-19: a global perspective. Humanities and Social Sciences Communications, 2021. 8(1).

[9]. 9.MSU_WALEED FAISAL A ALFAISAL_21.01.2025.pdf.

[10]. 10.Al-Yasin, Y. and A.A. Dashti, Foreign countries and U.S. public relations firms: The case of three persian gulf states. Journal of Promotion Management, 2009. 14(3-4): p. 355-374.

[11]. 11.Javid, M. and F.J. Hasanov, Determinants of remittance outflows: The case of Saudi Arabia. OPEC Energy Review, 2023. 47(4): p. 320-335.

[12]. 12.Abadi, J., Constraints and Adjustments in the US–Yemeni Relations. Contemporary Review of the Middle East, 2021. 8(3): p. 307-337.

[13]. 13.Abadi, J., Saudi Arabia’s rapprochement with Israel: The national security imperatives. Middle Eastern Studies, 2019. 55(3): p. 433-449.

[14]. 14.Özoral, B., The Examination of the Identities Defining Saudi Arabia’s Foreign Policy. Türkiye Ortadoğu Çalışmaları Dergisi, 2023. 10(1): p. 15-43.

[15]. 15.Ait Soussane, J., D. Mansouri, and Z. Mansouri, Impact of the divestment of Spanish FDI on economic growth of Morocco: an econometric analysis of 13 country-of-origin. Journal of Chinese Economic and Foreign Trade Studies, 2023. 16(1): p. 40-54.

[16]. 16.Sule, B., The Evolution of Religious Influence on Policy: A Review of Historical and Contemporary Studies. Religion and Policy Journal, 2023. 1(1): p. 22-26.

[17]. 17.Lawrence, M., et al., Global polycrisis: the causal mechanisms of crisis entanglement. Global Sustainability, 2024. 7.

[18]. 18.Peez, A., Is Multi-Method Research More Convincing Than Single-Method Research? An Analysis of International Relations Journal Articles, 1980–2018. Security Studies, 2023. 33(1): p. 55-87.

[19]. 19.Tabash, M.I., et al., Exploring the carbon footprints of economic growth, foreign investment, energy dependency and financial development: does EKC work in GCC region? Management of Environmental Quality: An International Journal, 2023. 34(2): p. 273-289.

[20]. 20.Al Naimi, S.M., Economic Diversification Trends in the Gulf: the Case of Saudi Arabia. Circ Econ Sustain, 2022. 2(1): p. 221-230.

[21]. 21.Berni, H.M.E., The Perceptual Shock of Qatar Foreign Policy in 2017 Crisis: Systemic Factors, Regional Struggles Versus Domestic Variables. Contemporary Review of the Middle East, 2021. 8(1): p. 96-119.

[22]. 22.Szatkowski, L., et al., in Development and evaluation of an intervention providing insight into the tobacco industry to prevent smoking uptake: a mixed-methods study. 2016: Southampton (UK).

[23]. 23.Al-Qahtani, F., Continuity and change in United States’ foreign policy towards Gulf region after the events of September 11th, 2001: A comparative vision between the Bush and Obama administrations. Review of Economics and Political Science, 2019. 4(1): p. 2-19.

[24]. 24.Cerioli, L., Saudi Arabian strategy reassessment since 2003: The emergence of a regional leadership via Neoclassical Realist lenses. International Area Studies Review, 2023. 26(3): p. 287-303.

[25]. 25.Quamar, M.M., The changing nature of the Pakistan factor in India-Gulf relations: An Indian perspective. Asian Affairs, 2018. 49(4): p. 625-644.

[26]. 26.Ali, A.A. and M.N. Sayed, Determinants of healthcare expenditures in GCC countries: A panel data analysis. Journal of Asian Finance, Economics and Business, 2020. 7(8): p. 705-714.

[27]. 27.Kuwait. Department of State publication. Background notes series, 1988: p. 1-8.

[28]. 28.Bajrei, S.S.S., S. Ismail, and S.M. Nor, Panel data analysis of ownership structure and board effectiveness influence on GCC bank performance. Economic Annals-XXI, 2018. 172(7-8): p. 4-8.

[29]. 29.Bianco, C. and G. Stansfield, The intra-GCC crises: Mapping GCC fragmentation after 2011. International Affairs, 2018. 94(3): p. 613-635.

[30]. 30.Aririguzoh, S., Communication competencies, culture and SDGs: effective processes to cross-cultural communication. Humanities and Social Sciences Communications, 2022. 9(1).

[31]. 31.Mason, R., Breaking the mold of small state classification? The broadening influence of United Arab Emirates foreign policy through effective military and bandwagoning strategies. Canadian Foreign Policy Journal, 2018. 24(1): p. 95-112.

[32]. 32.Hasan, Q.M., et al., When the law is unclear: challenges and opportunities for data and information exchange in the Tigris-Euphrates and Indus river basins. Water Policy, 2023. 25(8): p. 780-796.

[33]. 33.Tichenor, M., et al., Global public policy in a quantified world: Sustainable Development Goals as epistemic infrastructures. Policy and Society, 2022. 41(4): p. 431-444.

[34]. 34.Safranchuk, I.A., et al., The dilemma of middlepowermanship in Central Asia: Prospects for hegemony. Russia in Global Affairs, 2022. 20(3): p. 116-133.

[35]. 35.Sears, D., A Gentle Whisper: Restorying the Narrative of Eleven Ministers to Create a Collective Voice in the Battle Against Burnout. 2023.

[36]. 36.Hanson, R.L. and E.S. Zeemering, Cooperation and conflict between state and local government. 2021: Bloomsbury Publishing PLC.

[37]. 37.Moshirzadeh, H. and M. Arefi, Foreign Policy Shift in Afghanistan during Ashraf Ghani's Presidency: A Cognitive Approach. Central Eurasia Studies, 2021. 14(2): p. 319-345.

[38]. 38.Gutiérrez De Terán Gómez-Benita, I., Oman and its traditional foreign policy: the economic costs of positive neutrality. Revista de Estudios Internacionales Mediterraneos, 2024(36): p. 218-240.

[39]. 39.Al Tamamy, S.M., Saudi Arabia and the Arab Spring:Opportunities and Challenges of Security. Journal of Arabian Studies, 2012. 2(2): p. 143-156.

[40]. 40.Beacon, R., P. King, and F. Conway, REFORM. 2024.

[41]. 41.Heibach, J., Public diplomacy and regional leadership struggles: the case of Saudi Arabia. International Politics, 2021. 61(1): p. 83-105.

[42]. 42.Bahgat, G., Security in the Persian Gulf: Perils and opportunities. Contemporary Security Policy, 2008. 29(2): p. 303-321.

[43]. 43.Nonneman, G., European Policies Towards the Gulf: Patterns, Dynamics, Evolution, and the case of the Qatar Blockade. Journal of Arabian Studies, 2020. 10(2): p. 278-304.

[44]. 44.Karabulatova, A. and L. Kim, Kazakhstan-Saudi Arabia: Foreign policy contacts and interaction in the context of Anti-Russian sanctions. Central Asia and the Caucasus, 2017. 18(1): p. 33-39.

[45]. 45.Almezaini, K., The politics of Gulf foreign aid_ from survival and solidarity to political and military influence. Third World Quarterly, 2024. 45(15-16): p. 2190-2207.

[46]. 46.Salih, T.K. and O.K. Hasan, The Saudi Variable in Chinese-Iranian Relations. Dirasat: Human and Social Sciences, 2025. 52(5).

[47]. 47.Admoni, A., Same reasons, different outcomes: Qatar’s policy on Israel up to 1996. Middle Eastern Studies, 2022. 58(6): p. 830-842.

[48]. 48.Bahgat, G., Security in the Gulf: The View from Oman. Middle East Policy, 2023. 30(1): p. 98-109.

[49]. 49.Tuglo, L.S., et al., Food safety knowledge, attitude, and hygiene practices of street-cooked food handlers in North Dayi District, Ghana. Environ Health Prev Med, 2021. 26(1): p. 54.

[50]. 50.Cengiz, S., Dynamics of Saudi Arabia–KRG Relations: From 2003 Iraq War to 2017 Referendum and Beyond. Contemporary Review of the Middle East, 2022. 9(3): p. 321-340.

[51]. 51.Aloufi, A. and H. Kim, Transition to a friendly neighbor: Saudi Arabia's Aid Odyssey. Korean Journal of International Studies, 2024. 22(3): p. 311-335.

[52]. 52.Haruna, S.M., Sectarianism and Fragmentation in the Muslim World: A Qur'anic and Hadith Perspective on the Causes, Consequences, and Path to Unity. Dirasah International Journal of Islamic Studies, 2025. 3(1): p. 42-63.

[53]. 53.Morshed, A., Assessing the Economic Impact of IFRS Adoption on Financial Transparency and Growth in the Arab Gulf Countries. Economies, 2024. 12(8).

[54]. 54.Mohammadzadeh, B., Beyond royal politics: state transformation and foreign policy in Saudi Arabia. Third World Quarterly, 2019. 40(8): p. 1571-1589.

[55]. 55.Athanasoulia, S., From ‘soft’ to ‘hard’ to ‘moderate’: Islam in the dilemmas of post-2011 Saudi foreign policy. Religions, 2020. 11(4).

[56]. 56.Leeds, B.A. and M. Mattes, Domestic interests, democracy, and foreign policy change. 2022: Cambridge University Press.

[57]. 57.Mason, N.M., T.S. Jayne, and N.v.d. Walle, Fertilizer subsidies and voting patterns: Political economy dimensions of input subsidy programs. 2013.

[58]. 58.Acuff, S.F., et al., Applying behavioral economics to understand changes in alcohol outcomes during the transition to adulthood: Longitudinal relations and differences by sex and race. Psychology of Addictive Behaviors, 2024. 38(4): p. 424.

[59]. 59.El Berni, H.M., The Negotiated Desecuritization Of Turkey in Saudi Foreign Policy. Middle East Policy, 2023. 30(2): p. 62-74.

[60]. 60.Watkins, E., The Middle Eastern environment. Selected papers of the 1995 conference of the British Society for Middle Eastern Studies. The Middle Eastern environment. Selected papers of the 1995 conference of the British Society for Middle Eastern Studies, 1995.

[61]. 61.Robledo, J.P., et al., Back to basics: A re-evaluation of the relevance of imprinting in the genesis of Bowlby's attachment theory. Front Psychol, 2022. 13: p. 1033746.

[62]. 62.Bianco, C., The GCC Monarchies: Perceptions of the Iranian Threat amid Shifting Geopolitics. International Spectator, 2020. 55(2): p. 92-107.

[63]. 63.Khan, H.H., S. Khan, and A. Ghafoor, Fintech adoption, the regulatory environment and bank stability: An empirical investigation from GCC economies. Borsa Istanbul Review, 2023. 23(6): p. 1263-1281.

[64]. 64.Özev, M.H., Nation Building in Saudi Arabia: From Rentierism to Territorial Nationalism. Journal of Humanity and Society (insan & toplum), 2024. 14(2): p. 164-188.

[65]. 65.Meckling, J. and J. Nahm, Strategic state capacity: how states counter opposition to climate policy. Comparative Political Studies, 2022. 55(3): p. 493-523.

[66]. 66.Nigjeh, A.M., H. Daheshiar, and N. Shafiee, Mutual Sources of Concern between Iran and Saudi Arabia; Why and How. Geopolitics Quarterly, 2023. 19(3): p. 273-298.

[67]. 67.Álvarez-Ossorio, I. and L.R. Garcia, The foreign policy of Qatar: From a mediating role to an active one. Revista Espanola de Ciencia Politica, 2021(56): p. 97-120.

[68]. 68.Giddings, B., M. Almehrej, and M. Cresciani, The Dilemma of Saudi Arabian Homes in Riyadh. Space and Culture, 2020. 26(1): p. 4-22.

[69]. 69.Ezbidi, B., When Security Imperatives meet Sectarian Temptations: the Tehran-Riyadh rivalry. Cogent Social Sciences, 2023. 9(1).

[70]. 70.Daher, J., One year after: Where is Saudi Arabia and Syria’s normalisation process? 2024, European University Institute.

[71]. 71.Bakir, A., Turkey’s security role in the Gulf region: exploring the case of a newcomer. Turkish Studies, 2023. 24(5): p. 809-831.

[72]. 72.Janardhan, N., Non-Ideological, Strategic Convergence of the Gulf States’ “Look East” and India’s “Think West” Policies. Journal of Arabian Studies, 2022. 12(2): p. 160-184.

[73]. 73.Colombo, S., Foreign Policy Activism in Saudi Arabia and Oman. Diverging Narratives and Stances towards the Syrian and Yemeni Conflicts. International Spectator, 2017. 52(2): p. 54-70.

[74]. 74.de Olazábal, I.D. and D.H. Martínez, Saudi Arabia’s foreign policy: Striking a balance between domestic and external factors. Revista Espanola de Ciencia Politica, 2021(56): p. 21-47.

[75]. 75.Abdel Aziz, G.A., The Saudi–US Alliance challenges and resilience, 2011: 2019. Review of Economics and Political Science, 2019. 8(3): p. 208-225.

[76]. 76.Shahab Ahmed, Z., Understanding Saudi Arabia's Influence on Pakistan: The Case of the Islamic Military Alliance to Fight Terrorism. Muslim World, 2019. 109(3): p. 308-326.

[77]. 77.Taylor Fain, W., John F. Kennedy and Harold Macmillan: Managing the 'Special relationship' in the persian gulf region, 1961-63. Middle Eastern Studies, 2002. 38(4): p. 95-122.

[78]. 78.Alshamli, I.S., Kingdom of Saudi Arabia's Foreign Policy: Challenges and Manifestations in Vision 2030 Context. 2023: Sultan Qaboos University (Oman).

[79]. 79.Amjad Abbas, K., et al., China’s Efforts to Bring Political Stability and Economic Prosperity in the Middle East: The Case of Mending the Saudi-Iran Ties. Perennial Journal of History, 2024. 5(1): p. 13-34.

[80]. 80.Percze, M., Role of Saudi Arabia and Egypt in the Yemeni Civil Wars. Journal of Central and Eastern European African Studies, 2024. 3(2): p. 51-65.

[81]. 81.Al-Shaqsi, A.A., External and Intra-state Factors Causing the Rise of the Arms Race Among Qatar, Saudi Arabia, and United Arab of Emirates: Historical and Contemporary Perspectives. 2023: Sultan Qaboos University (Oman).

[82]. 82.El Amine, R., The GCC countries diplomatic approaches and its impact on economic development: a comparative study of the UAE, Saudi Arabia, Qatar, and Kuwait. 2023, Notre Dame University-Louaize.

[83]. 83.Ostřanský, J., F. Sarmiento, and S. Nikiema, Why Is Investment Treaty and Investor–State Dispute Settlement Reform Needed? 2025.

[84]. 84.Zhang, Y., The EU’s Democratic Dilemma: Assessing the Rise and Ramifications of Technocratic Government. Sage Open, 2024. 14(4).

[85]. 85.Rettig, E., When regional energy cooperation fails: learning from the struggles of Northeast Asia’s joint oil import mechanism. Cambridge Review of International Affairs, 2024. 37(5): p. 637-664.

[86]. 86.Erdogan, A., Saudi foreign policy doctrine post‐2011: The Iranian factor and balance of threat. Digest of Middle East Studies, 2022. 31(1): p. 6-24.

[87]. 87.Piazza, B.A., The foreign policy of post-Mubarak Egypt and the strengthening of relations with Saudi Arabia: balancing between economic vulnerability and regional and regime security. Journal of North African Studies, 2019. 24(3): p. 401-425.

[88]. 88.PehlİVan, S.B., Factors Determining the State Behavior of Saudi Arabia as a Regional Power. Akademik Tarih ve Dusunce Dergisi, 2023.

[89]. 89.Schechterman, B., Political Instability in Saudi Arabia and Its Implications, in The Middle East. 2023, Routledge. p. 233-244.

[90]. 90.Younis Ahmad, S., Confidence Building Measures (CBMs) between India and Pakistan. Journal of Islamic World and Politics, 2023. 7(1): p. 109-118.

[91]. 91.El-Dessouki, A. and O.R. Mansour, Small states and strategic hedging: the United Arab Emirates’ policy towards Iran. Review of Economics and Political Science, 2020. 8(5): p. 394-407.

[92]. 92.Asere, G.F., et al., Economic Conflicts: Understanding Dynamics, Impacts, and Resolution Strategies. Journal of Exceptional Multidisciplinary Research, 2024. 1(1): p. 8-14.

[93]. 93.Podeh, E., " Talking to the Enemy": Clandestine and Public Encounters for Peace between Israel and Syria (1948–2023). Israel Studies, 2024. 29(2): p. 30-60.

[94]. 94.Robinson, D.K., et al., Policy lensing of future-oriented strategic intelligence: An experiment connecting foresight with decision making contexts. Technological forecasting and social change, 2021. 169: p. 120803.

[95]. 95.Payne, R.A. Trump and American Foreign policy; A threat to peace and prosperity. in Prepared for the annual meeting of the international studies association. 2017.

[96]. 96.Rosato, S., Intentions in great power politics: Uncertainty and the roots of conflict. 2021: Yale University Press.

[97]. 97.Bowen, R.C., The Role of School Leadership in Setting the Conditions for Impactful, Sustained Social Justice Professional Development. 2024, Antioch University.

[98]. 98.Adanma, U.M. and E.O. Ogunbiyi, A comparative review of global environmental policies for promoting sustainable development and economic growth. International Journal of Applied Research in Social Sciences, 2024. 6(5): p. 954-977.

[99]. 99.Shi, H. and H. Zheng, Spillover connection between oil prices, energy risk exposure, and financial stability: implications for the COVID-19 pandemic. Environ Sci Pollut Res Int, 2022. 29(52): p. 78683-78697.

[100]. 100.Gollin, D. and J.P. Kaboski, New views of structural transformation: insights from recent literature. Oxford Development Studies, 2023. 51(4): p. 339-361.

[101]. 101.Pasha, A.K., Saudi Arabia and the Iranian Nuclear Deal. Contemporary Review of the Middle East, 2016. 3(4): p. 387-404.

[102]. 102.Shannon, K.J., ‘I'm glad I'm not a Saudi woman’: the First Gulf War and US encounters with Saudi gender relations. Cambridge Review of International Affairs, 2014. 27(3): p. 553-573.

[103]. 103.Debre, M.J., Legitimation, regime survival, and shifting alliances in the Arab League: Explaining sanction politics during the Arab Spring. International Political Science Review, 2020. 42(4): p. 516-530.

[104]. 104.Bargués, P., From ‘Resilience’to Strategic Autonomy: A Shift in the Implementation of the Global Strategy? EU-LISTCO Policy Papers, 2021. 9: p. 1-16.

[105]. 105.Talebi, R., The Relationship between the Centre and Periphery in the Islamic Republic of Iran, and the Implications of Change and Succession for the Country’s Political Stability. Open Journal of Political Science, 2024. 14(04): p. 679-719.

[106]. 106.Choudhari, A., New Regionalism and Norm Creation: A Case of Shanghai Cooperation Organization. Journal of Strategic Security, 2024. 17(1): p. 100-111.

[107]. 107.Bremmer, I., The power of crisis: how three threats–and our response–will change the world. 2022: Simon and Schuster.

[108]. 108.Roelofs, P., Good Governance in Nigeria: rethinking accountability and transparency in the twenty-first century. 2023: Cambridge University Press.

[109]. 109.Paudel, D.R. and R.K. KC, Effectiveness of Accountability Mechanism of Local Governments in Nepal. Available at SSRN 5086514, 2025.

[110]. 110.Arthur, D.J. and G.W. Winch, A conceptual framework to evaluate scenarios and futures, in Improving and Enhancing Scenario Planning. 2025, Edward Elgar Publishing. p. 406-435.

[111]. 111.Picione, R.D.L. and U. Lozzi, Uncertainty as a constitutive condition of human experience: Paradoxes and complexity of sensemaking in the face of the crisis and uncertainty. International Journal of Psychoanalysis and Education: Subject, Action & Society, 2021. 1(2): p. 14-53.

[112]. 112.Ullah, H.A., et al., Governance Challenges and Democratic Instability in Pakistan: An Islamic Perspective on Justice, Accountability, and Sustainable Development. International Research Journal of Arts, Humanities and Social Sciences, 2025. 2(02): p. 538-551.